Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies I love chocolate chip cookies, they're my favorite cookie. I grew up making batches of these, reading the recipe right off the Nestle bag for Toll House cookies. But it wasn't until I watched Alton Brown's Good Eats episode on these popular cookies that I discovered there was an entire world of chemistry behind my favorite little indulgence. Whether or not you melt the butter, use butter-flavored shortening, adjust the ratio of brown to white sugar, even the protein count of the flour you choose.. all of it can change this cookie from thin and crispy to puffy or chewy. I wanted a thick, chewy cookie for the cookie plate at the wedding, so I went with a slightly modified version of Alton's "The Chewy". I'm out of bread flour, which he included because the higher protein count of bread flour contributes to the texture, so instead I used a blend of whole wheat and all-purpose to bring the protein count up. (And also because I thought it might contribute an interesting flavor.) I found that adding the whole wheat gave the cookie more body and decreased some of the sweetness. This made my husband happy since many American desserts are much too sweet for him. I liked the thick, chewy texture and the subtler flavor -- this is the perfect cookie for dunking in cold milk. Cookie with Milk

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies [printable recipe]

Adapted from Alton Brown, Food Network
Makes approximately 40 cookies

Melt butter and add to the work bowl of your mixer. Add sugar and brown sugar, cream together1 on medium speed. Add egg, egg yolk, milk and vanilla, mixing until thoroughly combined. Slowly add flour, salt and baking soda2 at a low speed and continue to mix until everything is thoroughly combined. Scrape down sides as needed. Stir in chocolate chips (or dump them in while on the lowest speed).

Chill dough for an hour or two, then preheat oven to 375F. Portion out 1 ounce cookie balls onto a parchment-lined baking sheet, placing cookies about 2" apart. Bake for 12 - 14 minutes until the edges turn golden brown. Remove to a rack to cool completely before storing in an air-tight container.


  1. "Cream together" means to beat the sugars and butter at moderate speed until the mixture is fluffy.
  2. I know all the cookie recipes lately call for sifting together the dry ingredients. I still don't do it, instead adding dry ingredients periodically and relying on my mixer to do the heavy lifting. While sifting is fast and easy in a food processor, I still have to wash an extra appliance, and if not, an extra sieve -- too much for this cook.